Knock it down and start again?

A few days ago I was taking a photograph of the Quennevais Precinct when a man stopped and asked what I was doing. When I told him I was standing for election he said: “Well, I live here and I think they should knock the whole place down and start again!” That’s a dramatic point of view, unlikely to be shared by many of the other residents, but it captures the sense that the Precinct is no longer fit for purpose.

Jersey’s second town?

Supposedly Les Quennevais is now the island’s “second town”, but is it really? If it’s a town then the precinct is the town centre, but does it look like a town centre? We all know it could be so much better. That’s not to do down the efforts of businesses and residents, who do the best they can with ageing buildings. What’s needed is a vision for a new Les Quennevais precinct. It is worth investigating whether a private company might be interested in buying the whole precinct for redevelopment, but this is a long shot, particularly given the complex issues of land and home ownership. Failing a complete redevelopment, there is still so much that could done. What if the car park went underground for example? Or imagine how stunning the little square off the precinct could be if it was developed by a creative architect or urban designer?

The square off the precinct: from this…
To this…?

I believe the precinct and Red Houses are both exciting opportunities for renovation. We should involve the community, local groups, businesses and government in turning Les Quennevais into a hub with services and shops that mean we will need to make fewer trips to town.

What do you think? Knock it down? Renovate? What needs to be provided? I’d love to hear your thoughts.

3 thoughts on “Knock it down and start again?

  1. This is a difficult one as the flat residents above the shops that own their flats, who will pay to get them reinstated? If it gets knocked down they lose their homes, which many have mortgages on, so filling them down and starting again is not an option

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yes, it could only be done if residents were willing sellers, which would mean a developer would have to pay well over the market price. But then again, if the opportunity was there to develop the site going perhaps one storey higher, so still quite low rise, then a developer might be interested.


  2. The whole area is crying out for redevelopment so Knock it down or renovate whichever is cheaper . It is old, tired and very unattractive and certainly doesn’t attract shoppers other than those who live in the area and don’t want to drive to town so use it out of necessity. . . Obviously the flat owners would have to be compensated in whatever way is appropriate but hopefully they would be given the opportunity to be a part of something so much better than what they have at the moment.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s